Speculative Fiction

Legends

I did not read all the stories, some because I haven't read anything by the authors. I will comment on the ones I did (or tried to) read.

King's story is well-written, it takes place after Roland has begun his search for the Tower but before the first book in the series; while entertaining, it reveals nothing new. Goodkind's piece fleshes out a bit of the prehistory of his world, though it's the same quality as the rest of his writing (take that as you will). I couldn't get into Le Guin's story, it may have been written far after the original trilogy and thus doesn't have the same kind of weight. Martin's piece is a little snippet of the history of Westeros, nothing profound but still enjoyable (unless I missed a significant name, which I might have). Feist's story is not too interesting and is not significant to Riftwar. Jordan's piece is about how Moraine gets Lan as her Warder, early on in her search for the Dragon Reborn. It has a goodly amount of backstory, mostly relating to the Aes Sedai.

Check the groups below and enter your email address to receive updates by email:

Robert Silverberg

Email Address:

The trackback URL for this entry is: http://speculativefiction.org/weblog/servlet/trackback/39


No trackbacks have been posted so far.


LeGuin's story...

was in fact written long, long after Earthsea, and several years after Tehanu. It actually gave me a certain amount of hope that she would return to the world and do it justice after smashing it to pieces in Tehanu, but instead, the books that expanded on this original short story remained mostly middle-of-the-road mediocrity. Clearly the reaction to Tehanu had been so strongly negative that she wasn't going to return to writing about the world in that mode, but still wanted to make some of the same points in a way that would at least be accepted as canon.

Trivia: Like Highlander 2, many people have declared that Tehanu does not exist.

Rating Notify me of new comments on this entry
From
Email
Homepage
Subject
Comment

Authors Tanya Huff
George RR Martin
Michelle Sagara West
Peg Kerr
Kij Johnson
CJ Cherryh
Steven Brust
Pamela Dean
Industry Making Light
Readers Library Of Babel
Outside of a Dog